Investment property lenders in Erie County, New York
Fat Boy Data analyzed investment property mortgage activity in Erie County, New York to show which lenders are making these loans, how often they approve, how often borrowers accept the offer, and how much they typically finance. 2,588 applications were decided by 176 lenders between 2023 and 2025.
Erie County at a glance
How Erie County compares
What the data shows
Premium Mortgage Corporation made the most investment property mortgages in Erie County, NY, 160 of them.
Tompkins Bank & Trust approved the highest share of applications among lenders with at least 20 decisions here, 100% of 22.
The typical investment property mortgage here is $165K, 65% smaller than the New York typical of $465K.
Each dot is one lender, placed at its approval rate. Hover for the name and sample size.
Investment property lenders in Erie County
| Lender | Approval | Approved | Taken up | Typical loan | Loans made | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | United Wholesale Mortgage, LLCBroker only | 89% | 275 / 308 | 100% | $165K | 274 |
| 2 | Premium Mortgage Corporation | 97% | 161 / 166 | 99% | $185K | 160 |
| 3 | Crosscountry Mortgage, LLC | 97% | 143 / 148 | 99% | $185K | 142 |
| 4 | Manufacturers and Traders Trust Company | 90% | 84 / 93 | 99% | $165K | 83 |
| 5 | Hunt Mortgage Corporation | 97% | 65 / 67 | 100% | $155K | 65 |
Ranked by lending volume. Approval is the share of decided applications a lender approved; taken up is the share of approvals the borrower accepted. Lenders with fewer than 20 decisions are marked as a limited sample and are never used for a “highest approval” claim. How these numbers are built.
Fat Boy found 171 more lenders.
Free. One email unlocks the whole market.
You are seeing the 5 largest investment property mortgage lenders in Erie County. Unlock every lender who decided one of these loans here, what they approved, how much borrowers actually took, and how far the nearest office is.
- Every lender, ranked
- Approval and take-up rates
- Typical loan and full range
- Nearest office and distance
- Branch count and how to apply
- How reachable each lender is
We email you the unlock link and occasional updates on your market. We may share your interest with mortgage providers so they can contact you. How we use your data. Unsubscribe any time.